其三,是“形骸化”的情况。根据“形骸化”规则来追究有限责任屏障之后的合伙人的个人责任,要把握的标准是:在特殊普通合伙中,只有当合伙人对合伙事务经营及财产的控制存在欺诈及不适用刺破规则就会导致对债权人严重不公的情况,才可适用该规则。
【作者简介】
何新容,南京审计学院法学院讲师,南京大学法学院博士研究生。姜冲,南京大学法学院讲师,法学博士。
【注释】Marilyn B.Cane and Helen R.Franco,“Limited Liability in Registered Limited Liability Partnerships:HowDoes the Florida RLLP Measure up?”20.Nov.L.Rev,Spring,1996,p.1230.
宋永新:《美国非公司型企业法》,社会科学文献出版社2000年版,第268-270页。
张杰:《对公司法人人格否认制度的思考——析新
公司法第
20条》,《行政与法》2006年第9期。
95U.S.v.Milwaukee Refrigerator Transit Co,142 F,2d 247(1905).
L.C.B Cowers,Principle of Modern Company Law,Seven Sons(Publisher)1979,2th edition,p.132.
Rebecca J.Hussy,“Revamping Veil Piercing for All Limited Liability Entities:Forcing the Common Law Doc-trine into the Statutory Age”,70 U.Cin.L.Rev,Fall,2001,p.95.
Colorado:Partnership Act§7-60-153;Minnesota:Partnership Act§323-14-13;North Dakota:Partnership Act§44-22-09.
Jason Broesder and Nicole Cottle,“The Wyoming Registered Limited Liability Partnership”,34 Land&WaterL.Rev,1999,p.139.
Gregory Huffman,“Creating the Legal Monster:The Expansion and Effect of Legal Malpractice Liability inNorth Carolina”,18 Campbell L.Rev,Winter,1996,p.121.
Carol.J.Miller,“LLPs:How Limited is Limited Liability?”53 J.Mo.B,MayJune,1997,p.65.
Rebecca J.Hussy,“Revamping Veil Piercing for All Limited Liability Entities:Forcing the Common Law Doc-trine into the Statutory Age”,70 U.Cin.L.Rev,Fall,2001,p.97.
Daniel S.Kleinberger,Agency,Partnerships,and LLCs,中信出版社2003年版,第464-465页。
Robert W.Hamilton,“Registered Limited Liability Partnerships:Present at the Birth(Nearly)”,66.Col.L.Rev,1995,p.1065.
Poonam Puri,“Judgment Proofing,the Profession Ethics,”Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics,Fall,2001,p.25.
Rebecca J.Hussy,“Revamping Veil Piercing for All Limited Liability Entities:Forcing the Common Law Doc-trine into the Statutory Age”,70 U.Cin.L.Rev,Fall,2001,p.100.
John H.Matheson,“The Doctrine of Piercing the Veil in an Era of Multiple Limited Liability Entities:an Op-portunity to Codify the Test for Waiving Owner’s Limited-Liability protection”,75 Wash.L.Rev,2000,p.147.
Rebecca J.Hussy,“Revamping Veil Piercing for All Limited Liability Entities:Forcing the Common Law Doc-trine into the Statutory Age”,70 U.Cin.L.Rev,Fall,2001,p.95.
Daniel J.Morrissey,“Piercing All the Veils:Applying an Established Doctrine to a New Business Order”,32Iowa J.Corp.L,Spring,2007,p.529.
Emily A.Lackey,“Piercing the Veil of Limited Liability in the Non-Corporate Setting”,55 Ark.L.Rev,2002,p.553.
Rebecca J.Hussy,“Revamping Veil Piercing for All Limited Liability Entities:Forcing the Common Law Doc-trine into the Statutory Age”,70 U.Cin.L.Rev,Fall,2001,p.96.
Carol R.Goforth,“Limiting the Liability of General Partners in LLPs:An Analysis of Statutory Alternatives”,75U.Oreg.L.Rev,Winter,1996,p.1139.
Rebecca J.Hussy,“Revamping Veil Piercing for All Limited Liability Entities:Forcing the Common Law Doc-trine into the Statutory Age”,70 U.Cin.L.Rev,Fall,2001,p.98.
Daniel J.Morrissey,“Piercing All the Veils:Applying an Established Doctrine to a New Business Order”,32Iowa J.Corp.L,Spring,2007,p.531.
Rebecca J.Hussy,“Revamping Veil Piercing for All Limited Liability Entities:Forcing the Common Law Doc-trine into the Statutory Age”,70 U.Cin.L.Rev,Fall,2001,p.97.
Rebecca J.Hussy,“Revamping Veil Piercing for All Limited Liability Entities:Forcing the Common Law Doc-trine into the Statutory Age”,70 U.Cin.L.Rev,Fall,2001,p.102
Emily A.Lackey,“Piercing the Veil of Limited Liability in the Non-Corporate Setting”,55 Ark.L.Rev,2002,p.554.
Jason Broesder and Nicole Cottle,“The Wyoming Registered Limited Liability Partnership”,34 Land&WaterL.Rev,1999,p.141.
Gregory Huffman,“Creating the Legal Monster:The Expansion and Effect of Legal Malpractice Liability inNorth Carolina”,18 Campbell L.Rev,Winter,1996,p.123.
Carol R.Goforth,“Limiting the Liability of General Partners in LLPs:An Analysis of Statutory Alternatives”,75U.Oreg.L.Rev,Winter,1996,p.1145.
Susan Saab Fortney,“Professional Responsibility and Liability Issues Related to Limited Liability Law Partner-ships”,39S.Tex.L.Rev,March,1998,p.399.
朱慈蕴:《公司法人人格否认法理研究》,法律出版社1999年版,第150-151页。
Rebecca J.Hussy,“Revamping Veil Piercing for All Limited Liability Entities:Forcing the Common Law Doc-trine into the Statutory Age”,70 U.Cin.L.Rev,Fall,2001,p.98.
Emily A.Lackey,“Piercing the Veil of Limited Liability in the Non-Corporate Setting”,55 Ark.L.Rev,2002,p.556.